Troubleshooting Guide

Start with the CLI or build output. It is the source of truth for publish and sync runs. Discourse notifications are useful, but they can fail when credentials, network access, or forum permissions are broken.

First Checks

Run from the Astro project root.

npx astro-discussion-bridge check-discourse \
  --discourse-url https://forum.example.com \
  --category-id 5 \
  --tags discussionbridge,docs

Then run the intended publish or sync command with --dry-run --details.

npx astro-discussion-bridge publish-and-sync src/content/docs \
  --dry-run \
  --details

Check:

• docs directory
• route base
• computed page URL
• topic ID
• category ID
• tags
• active target
• dry-run status
• skip or failure reason

Missing API Credentials

Symptom:

Missing required configuration: DISCOURSE_API_KEY or --api-key, plus DISCOURSE_POST_AS or --post-as (legacy API-username controls remain fallback-compatible)

Fix:

• set preferred DISCOURSE_POST_AS or --post-as
• use DISCOURSE_API_USERNAME / --api-username only as a compatibility fallback
• set DISCOURSE_API_KEY
• run from the same shell session where the variables are set
• use hosting-provider encrypted environment variables for deployed builds

PowerShell:

$env:DISCOURSE_POST_AS="discussbridge-bot"
$env:DISCOURSE_API_KEY="paste-publishing-key-here"

Title Is Too Short

Symptom:

Title is too short

Fix:

• give the Astro page a clearer title
• use a title template or prefix when available
• pass a site-appropriate --title-min-length
• use --dry-run --details before publishing

Title Already Exists

Symptom:

Title has already been used

Fix:

• check whether the topic already exists
• confirm the page does not already have discourseTopicId
• confirm the page URL and route base are correct
• use check-discourse --page-url to test whether the existing topic can be resolved
• link the page to the existing topic when ownership is clear

Embed URL Already Taken

Symptom:

Embed url has already been taken

Cause:

Discourse may already have a topic for the Astro page URL, often created by native embedding before the CLI published it.

Fix:

npx astro-discussion-bridge check-discourse \
  --discourse-url https://forum.example.com \
  --category-id 5 \
  --page-url https://docs.example.com/example-page/

If the bridge can reconcile the existing topic, rerun publish/sync with a key that can read the required lookup endpoints. If the key cannot read /embed/info or exact URL search, use a broader diagnostics key or manually link the page with discourseTopicId after confirming ownership.

Body Too Long

Symptom:

Discourse rejects the post body, or local preflight reports the body exceeds maxPostLength.

Fix:

• use discussionSummary for long or rich pages
• increase --max-post-length only when the Discourse site allows it
• keep large tables, long generated content, and highly designed Astro content on the Astro page
• include a source link back to Astro

Tag Problems

Symptoms:

• too many tags
• tag too long
• tag does not exist
• API user cannot tag topics
• API user cannot create tags

Fix:

• verify Discourse tag settings
• verify max_tags_per_topic
• verify max_tag_length
• create tags in advance
• give the bot user permission to tag topics
• use check-discourse --tags tag1,tag2

Wrong Category

Fix:

• confirm the category ID in Discourse
• run check-discourse --category-id ID
• verify lane config and CLI flags
• verify page frontmatter overrides
• rerun sync with --dry-run --details

Duplicate Managed Topic Or Page URL

Symptom:

Multiple managed pages in this run use the same Discourse topic ID

or:

Multiple managed pages in this run use the same page URL

Cause:

More than one Astro source page in the same publish/sync run claims ownership of the same Discourse companion topic or source page URL.

Fix:

• choose one Astro page as the managed source
• make comparison/demo pages display-only
• add discussionSync: false to pages that should render the topic without updating the first post
• remove duplicate discourseTopicId frontmatter from pages that should not render or update the topic
• split lanes so only the intended source page is included in a management run
• give each managed page its own Discourse topic when each page needs independent sync

This check runs before Discourse writes, including during --dry-run.

Comments Do Not Refresh

For full mode:

• confirm the page has discourseTopicId
• confirm Discourse topic JSON is readable
• configure replies.refreshEndpoint when browser CORS blocks direct reads
• confirm the same-origin proxy route is deployed
• refresh the Astro page after a new Discourse reply

For simple mode:

• confirm the Discourse embedding host is allowed
• remember that Discourse controls the rendered output
• visible like counts may not appear

For fullInteractive mode:

• confirm Embed full app is enabled
• confirm Embed full app signin flow is configured appropriately
• test logged-in and logged-out behavior
• test on a page where comments start below the first viewport

Discourse Refused to Connect

Fix:

• confirm embedding host settings
• confirm the Astro domain exactly matches the allowed host
• confirm Embed full app settings if using fullInteractive
• confirm HTTPS and certificate status
• check browser console for frame or CSP errors

Discourse Offline

Publish/sync commands should fail clearly. Do not treat a successful Astro build as proof that Discourse publishing succeeded.

For pages:

• simple and fullInteractive should leave the Astro page shell intact
• full should show a temporary unavailable state when it cannot fetch replies
• the full discussion link should remain available when the topic URL is known

Deleted Topic

If a linked Discourse topic is deleted, do not automatically recreate it. The bridge cannot safely know whether deletion was intentional.

Fix:

• confirm whether the topic was deleted intentionally
• decide whether to restore, relink, or create a replacement
• use an explicit repair workflow when available
• avoid guessing when ownership cannot be proven

Deleted First Post

If the first post is missing, sync should fail clearly. The first post is the managed companion content.

Fix:

• confirm the topic state in Discourse
• restore the first post if appropriate
• decide whether relinking or re-importing is safer
• avoid silently creating replacement content in an active discussion

Active Target Mismatch

Symptom:

A page is skipped because it has discussionTarget but the command used a different target or no target.

Fix:

npx astro-discussion-bridge sync-existing src/content/docs --target community

Use target labels to avoid syncing one page to the wrong Discourse instance or community lane.

Stale Cloudflare or CDN Cache

If Discourse or Astro appears stale after a confirmed sync or deploy:

• trust the CLI/build output first
• verify the Discourse edit history or topic JSON
• verify the deployed Astro commit
• test with a cache-bypassing request
• clear the relevant Cloudflare cache when necessary

Do not classify the sync as failed until cache has been ruled out.

Failure Notifications

Use --notify-on-failure to send a best-effort Discourse private message to configured recipients.

npx astro-discussion-bridge publish-and-sync src/content/docs \
  --notify-on-failure \
  --notify-recipients PhilH

Notifications use Discourse PM behavior. They are helpful, but the CLI/build log remains authoritative.